Barriers to trade in food staples in West Africa: an analytical review
Author (s)
Jakob Engel and Marie-Agnès Jouanjean
Introduction
The West African region faces many challenges to exploiting the potential contribution of increased intra-regional trade in food staples to food security. This problem is all the more pressing as the nature of trade and agricultural production in the region is in a process of great flux. “In the medium term,” Josserand (2013, p. 8) argues, “population growth, urbanisation and the transformation of West African agriculture will redefine regional trade flows of basic foods -the increase in trade is expected to far outpace the tripling in regional food production.” Addressing these changes will require a better understanding both of the barriers to and drivers of regional trade in food staples.
The World Bank is in the process of launching an ambitious three-year research programme, “Integrating Regional Markets in Food Staples in West Africa,” that aims to fill knowledge gaps on trade in food staples in the West African region. It aims to provide a better understanding of the current realities of regional food staples trade in West Africa and explore regional policy responses and institutional modalities to better promote responses to food crises.
Review of current state of knowledge
Regional agricultural trade policies and institutions in West Africa
Both regional economic communities, ECOWAS and UEMOA, have developed comprehensive agricultural and trade policy frameworks with the objective of improving coordination and increasing trade integration between their member states. This process is further advanced in UEMOA, where a surveillance mechanism for macroeconomic convergence has been established, along with a customs union and the abolition of tariffs or quotas on intraregional trade in domestic products. Non-UEMOA ECOWAS member states agreed in 2006 to join the existing UEMOA Common External Tariff (CET) and a fifth tariff band (at 35 per cent) was added in 2009 at the behest of Nigeria. However, the CET has not yet been adopted throughout the ECOWAS region. However, in practice many countries se the CET as providing insufficient protection for strategic priority commodities, driving unpredictable tariff and non-tariff barriers (Rolland, 2011).
At the regional level, there are moreover few non-governmental institutions to promote greater integration. Pannhausen and Untied (2010) provide an overview of some of the existing organisations, including the Réseau des Organisations Paysannes et des Producteurs Agricoles de L’Afrique de l’Ouest (ROPPA), Réseau des Chambres d’Agriculture de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (RECAO) and Réseau des Opérateurs Economiques du Secteur agroalimentaire de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (ROESAO) and Afrique Verte International. Finally, the Alliance Globale pour l’Initiative Résilience – Sahel (AGIR,), first proposed in 2012 aims at uniting the international community around the West African agenda of food security and nutrition. However, little information exists on the role, membership or effectiveness of these. Further, as low private sector awareness of the ETLS appears to be a recurring theme throughout the ETLS gap analysis (USAID 2011 in Harris et al 2012), the linkages between RECs, transnational agricultural interest groups and producers and traders is a pertinent area for further analysis.
Transparency and predictability of national agricultural trade policies – impact on food security and food price volatility.
Analytical studies of trade and food security in West Africa often approach agricultural trade as a domestic price and supply stabilisation tool in the event of food crises. The mixed results of past regional and multilateral trade liberalisation on incentives to trade and on food security, paired with an increase in international food prices and volatility, supported the decision of various countries in ECOWAS to adopt temporary trade measures and to reinstate self-sufficiency objectives in their agricultural policy. Rolland and Alpha (2008) list some of the temporary export restrictions or prohibitions, including Guinea’s export ban on all food to neighbouring countries, Burkina Faso decision to control or restrict exports of local cereals, and Senegal’s prohibition of rice exports.
Galtier (2012) discriminates among three main causes of food price volatility:
- “Natural instability” stemming from harvest concentration in time and sensitivity to natural hazards such as rainfall, disease and attacks by pests;
- “Imported instability” caused by international price instability being passed on through imports and exports;
- “Endogenous instability” caused by the dysfunction of domestic markets.
Drivers of trade in food staples in Western Africa
In order to circumvent the unreliability of official data in the analysis of food staples trade flows in Western Africa, various studies choose to adopt other methodologies based on the analysis of production and trade basins. Haggblade et al. (2012) combine data on the spatial distribution of rural and urban population, maps of differing food staples zones, crop production data and consumption patterns as described by an array of recent households’ surveys, in order to map major urban food markets as well as principal surplus zones. Accordingly, they are able to identify the geographic extent of major staple food market sheds in West Africa and the major trade corridors linking surplus and deficit areas.
Using spatial analysis to examine surplus and deficit production areas is particularly relevant to the analysis of trade in food staples in West Africa. Countries in this region appear as natural partners for food staples trade, as different sub-regions have comparative advantages in complementary food staples, with diverse ecosystems yielding a wide range of produce.
West Africa is therefore often divided into three agro-ecological zones relating to various farming systems and consumption patterns. In addition to the north-south movement of particular commodities for export, three basins are identified based on their trade flows in cereals: the West, Central, and East basins. However, as highlighted by Haggblade et al (2012), surplus food producing zones in Africa, unlike many regions of the world, lie across the border from the markets they serve, with political borders often separating surplus food production zones from deficit markets they would normally serve.
Non-tariff barriers (NTBs) to trade in food staples
Successful regional integration experiences elsewhere in the world highlight that tackling tariff barriers is a necessary but not sufficient to enhance trade. NTBs, whether protectionist in intent or not, raise trade costs and inhibit regional trade. Western Africa is no exception and efforts to facilitate trade in the region must also aim to address NTBs. While Cissoko et al (2012) argue that the impact of NTBs in West Africa is less harmful to agricultural trade than they are outside of the region, the prevalence of particularly non-formal measures is large and widely discussed in the literature. Therefore, even if NTBs are less important in Western Africa than in other regions of the world, they remain difficult to address.
A growing literature provides evidence about the nature and the extent of non-tariff barriers in agricultural trade in West Africa. As summarised in Harris et al (2011, 3-4) these include gaps between regional agreements, national legislation and implementation; limited private sector knowledge of free trade protocols; strong incentives for informal trade; non-compliance with existing tariffs; the widespread imposition of non-tariff barriers (NTBs); the non-functioning of the Inter-States Road Transit (ISRT) regime; non-recognition of certificates or origin and noncompliance with truck axle loads; and the challenges of joint membership for members of both ECOWAS and UEMOA.
For example, Ghana imposes bans and restrictions, often for months at a time on unprocessed agricultural times, Burkina Faso imposes seasonal restrictions on maize, and Senegal and Togo mandate escort services for transit goods. Harris et al (2011) argue that this is in part driven by the pace of liberalisation and integration: fears of inadequate protection for local producers has facilitated the proliferation of NTBs in the region.
Existing projects
Compared to other regions in Africa, West Africa benefits from relatively little ongoing research on trade in food staples, though this has been changing. The main projects focused specifically on regional trade in food staples in this area are funded by USAID, under the West Africa Trade Hub (since 2009). The ATP and E-ATP projects under this programme aim to increase value and volume of intra-regional agricultural trade by reducing trade barriers and enhancing linkages among producers, suppliers, distributors and processors as well as improve the efficiency in transactions through improved information systems.
The EU, GIZ, DFID, AFD, CIDA and other donor agencies also all have programmes focused on agriculture, trade and regional integration in the region. The €600m 10th EDF Regional Programme for West Africa (2008-13) is primarily targeted towards deepening regional cooperation, increasing competitiveness, and EPA negotiations support. GIZ’s Support Programme for the ECOWAS Commission has a targeted focus on ETLS implementation. Finally, the World Bank’s $197m ‘West Africa Transport and Transit Facilitation Project’ is improving road and rail infrastructure and implementing transit and transport facilitation measures along the Tema-Ouagadougou-Bamako corridor.
Identifying the impact of domestic policies on food staple price levels and volatility
Nature of the research gap
Following the increase in international food prices and volatility since 2008, various countries in ECOWAS reinstated self-sufficiency objectives in their agricultural policy. However, analyses show that endogenous instability is more significant than imported instability for food staple price volatility in many African countries. But more information is necessary on the importance of endogenous causes of food price volatility.
Relevance to project aims Central to this workstream is understanding the endogenous drivers of food price levels and their volatility in Western Africa in order to address bottlenecks in the development of regional food staples value chains. The project concept note points to various policies being implemented by West African governments (e.g. Nigeria’s decision to increase border taxation on rice). A corollary of this would be to assess potential complementary policies to cushion adverse impacts of trade reforms and in particular to identify what kind of safety net programmes could cushion households most vulnerable to food insecurity, particularly in the case of food price spikes. Having improved analysis and evidence on current policies may provide clearer evidence on potential paths for action.
Cluster 2: The politics of regional and national agricultural trade policy development and implementation
Assessing progress in and barriers to the implementation of ECOWAP and the PAU
Both the ECOWAP and the PAU are intended to support greater harmonisation of agricultural policies and increased cooperation and regional coordination. However, numerous sources discuss the incomplete implementation of the two regional agricultural policies (for example Savodogo 2009, Rolland and Alpha 2011), and no evaluation of either the extent of their implementation or their impact has been conducted thus far. It is unclear who has benefited and what the impact on investment, production and trade has been. There has also been no comprehensive assessment of the compatibility and coherence between the two agricultural frameworks, between these and formal domestic policies, and with the ETLS. Thus, it is central to understand first how compatible regional and domestic legal frameworks are. Secondly, it would be important to determine what the political and institutional barriers to their implementation within selected countries are.
Relevance to project aims
Understanding the political drivers of greater integration as well as the institutional (and capacity-related) barriers to this process could help improve understanding of potential duplication of efforts within already over-burdened RECs, and as Chambers et al. (2011) argue, “prevent the sort of policy incoherence that can result from overlapping mandates and memberships.”
Conclusion
The World Bank’s focus on examining regional trade in food staples in the West African region is highly timely and contributes to a growing body of work that is, however, still rather small considering the size of the region in terms of population and product diversity. In addition to the research priorities identified in the previous section, tentative recommendations emerging from this review include the following:
- Prioritising intra-regional trade as an alternative to national self-sufficiency– Given the small size of domestic markets in many West African countries and the great variation in production, focusing on achieving similar objectives at the regional or sub-regional level is more realistically attainable and less likely to result in shortages than pursuing this at the national level.
- Cross-border planning and integration of prioritised food staple value chains – A corollary of this is that countries will need support (including from donors) to identify barriers and foster value chain development for key food staples. This approach will require coordination at the regional level, as prioritised value chains should aim for some degree of complementarity with those of neighbouring countries.
- Greater focus on implementation – It is not the absence of formal regional trade integration but rather its too superficial and instable implementation, as well as formal and informal nontariff barriers that have prevented the development of regional food staples value chains. Thus, the political and economic factors influencing the level of implementation of regional agreements is of central relevance and should be assessed before further ambitious region-wide commitments are made.
- Focus on environmental and demographic trends – It is important to address changing climatic and demographic trends that will inevitably affect both the supply and demand for food staples. Urban consumers have long been the drivers of agricultural policy formulation with the aim to provide cheap food to large cities. With the increase in urban population, this trend is unlikely to change. Yet, policies will have to both enable an increase in supply as well as to support better connections to surplus areas in order to continue to supply domestic food to urban areas rather than fully relying on imports to address the increase in demand. Modelling the changing nature of demand and how trade and agricultural policy will likely need to respond would therefore be of great utility, particularly in predicting future shortages as well as in recognising which corridors connect surplus agricultural production areas with urban and peri-urban areas.]
- Recognising how regional integration impacts on the distribution of rents – As past World Bank work on trade reforms in East Africa has shown (Aksoy and Onal 2011), the success and sustainability of such reforms differs from country to country and depends on having a degree of consensus among political elites, the private sector and other leading stakeholders. This requires looking at reforms as multi-stage dynamic processes and analysing in detail the incentives different actors are likely to face under different scenarios.
- Focus on recognition rather than harmonisation – Addressing the prevalence of NTBs should be a priority, but in many cases taking smaller steps to mitigate their impact may be more easily feasible than large-scale reforms. For example, moving towards mutual recognition (for example in the case of SPS) may be more promising than pressing for regional harmonisation (see Bromley et al 2011).
- A holistic approach to removing barriers –In order for regional integration to be a tool for enhanced food security, both supply and demand side bottlenecks should be identified and addressed jointly. Developing agricultural trade-related services, increase competition and reduce marketing prices, require that agricultural production reaches a minimum threshold. At the same time, producers’ decision to participate to the market depends both on access to higher productivity agricultural production technologies facilitated by an access to extension services and to inputs as well as on access and incentives to participate to output markets, with the profitability of selling agricultural outputs depending on the availability of various value chain logistic services, from post-harvest to transport services.
- Integration of complementary policies – As numerous studies have shown, the food security impact of regional and multilateral trade reforms (including liberalisation and regional integration) depends greatly on how prices are transmitted through the economy (see McCorriston et al 2013). As such, ensuring coherence between agricultural and trade policies and planning in advance how social protection and safety net policies can shield against negative consequences for adversely affected groups and individual is essential
- Better data – While significant efforts have been made in recent years, particularly led and financed by donors, to improve the collection and quality of data on prices, food production and other key variables in this area, we still face substantial data gaps that limit the ability to devise evidence based trade and agricultural policies.
- Promoting private sector involvement in R&D – Currently the West African region lags behind others in providing incentives for agricultural research. While donors and foundations are providing much of this support, it still remains very sporadic and the lack of consistent policies or clear promotion of public-private partnerships provides disincentives for private sector actors to engage.
492 Commentaires. En écrire un nouveau
legitimate canadian pharmacy: CanRx Direct – canadian pharmacy online
https://canrxdirect.com/# legitimate canadian pharmacies
mexican drugstore online mexico drug stores pharmacies buying prescription drugs in mexico online
https://canrxdirect.shop/# the canadian drugstore
indian pharmacy online: IndiMeds Direct – online pharmacy india
http://tijuanameds.com/# TijuanaMeds
mexican rx online mexican pharmaceuticals online TijuanaMeds
http://canrxdirect.com/# ed meds online canada
IndiMeds Direct: world pharmacy india – indian pharmacy paypal
IndiMeds Direct indian pharmacy IndiMeds Direct
canadian pharmacy prices: canada pharmacy 24h – canadian drugs online
https://tijuanameds.shop/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
pharmacy rx world canada: CanRx Direct – canadian pharmacy antibiotics
http://canrxdirect.com/# canada drugstore pharmacy rx
india pharmacy mail order reputable indian pharmacies п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
canadian drugs online: CanRx Direct – canadian pharmacy service
http://canrxdirect.com/# canadapharmacyonline com
medication from mexico pharmacy: TijuanaMeds – medication from mexico pharmacy
mail order pharmacy india buy prescription drugs from india indian pharmacy online
doc morris pharmacy artane: Pharma Connect USA – PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Confiance: materiel mГ©dical autour de moi – Pharma Confiance
https://pharmajetzt.com/# Pharma Jetzt
online pharmacy overnight delivery: india online pharmacy – accutane online pharmacy uk
med apotheek: pharmacy online netherlands – online apotheek zonder recept ervaringen
http://pharmajetzt.com/# PharmaJetzt
good pill pharmacy Pharma Connect USA PharmaConnectUSA
MedicijnPunt: Medicijn Punt – MedicijnPunt
Trimox: PharmaConnectUSA – Pharma Connect USA
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# medikamente preisvergleich testsieger
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# amoxicillin boots pharmacy
PharmaConnectUSA: Pharma Connect USA – PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Jetzt online apotheken Pharma Jetzt
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – sans culotte lourdes
Medicijn Punt: Medicijn Punt – internetapotheek
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# online pharmacy that sells percocet
tacrolimus pharmacy PharmaConnectUSA Nootropil
medikament online: PharmaJetzt – online apotek
http://pharmajetzt.com/# PharmaJetzt
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# Pharma Connect USA
Pharma Connect USA: Pharma Connect USA – publix pharmacy doxycycline
MedicijnPunt: apotheek webshop – MedicijnPunt
medicijnen bestellen online apotheek on line Medicijn Punt
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Jetzt: Pharma Jetzt – online apotheke germany
Pharma Jetzt: versandapotheke vergleich – apotheke online gГјnstig
apothwke: versand apotheke – PharmaJetzt
pharmacie notre dame de santГ© Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# celebrex pharmacy prices
avis new pharma: Pharma Confiance – amoxicilline prix sans ordonnance
god pour chat: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Jetzt: Pharma Jetzt – Pharma Jetzt
pharmacie de garde lyon 3 aujourd’hui monuril pharmacie Pharma Confiance
https://medicijnpunt.com/# MedicijnPunt
Pharma Jetzt: PharmaJetzt – apotheeke
PharmaJetzt: online spotheke – PharmaJetzt
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# shop apotheke germany
PharmaConnectUSA: lipitor $4 copay pharmacy – viagra from mexico pharmacy
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# Pharma Connect USA
medizin bestellen PharmaJetzt tabletten kaufen
laboratoire de garde marseille: Pharma Confiance – dГ©odorant caudalie avis
PharmaConnectUSA: PharmaConnectUSA – PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Jetzt: medikamente bestellen online – medikamente bestellen sofort
https://pharmaconfiance.com/# pharmacie au tour de moi
uw apotheek: п»їmedicijnen bestellen – online apotheek goedkoper
acheter viagra cialis sans ordonnance: boutique ghd – Pharma Confiance
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# online apotheke deutschland
PharmaConnectUSA: Pharma Connect USA – Pharma Connect USA
Medicijn Punt: medicatie apotheker – wat is mijn apotheek
Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance antitussif chien naturel
compounding pharmacy finasteride: Pharma Connect USA – Pharma Connect USA
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# PharmaConnectUSA
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# Pharma Connect USA
medicijnen kopen online: medicijn bestellen – MedicijnPunt
Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance
https://medicijnpunt.com/# apotheek spanje online
Medicijn Punt: digitale apotheek – apotek online
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – guigoz rose
online pharmacy stock order viagra Pharma Connect USA Pharma Connect USA
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# your pharmacy host buy viagra
https://medicijnpunt.shop/# MedicijnPunt
Medicijn Punt: MedicijnPunt – MedicijnPunt
PharmaJetzt: PharmaJetzt – luitpold apotheke bad steben
Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# where to buy viagra in malaysia pharmacy
internetapotheek nederland: Medicijn Punt – online medicijnen bestellen apotheek
PharmaConnectUSA: Pharma Connect USA – viagra pharmacy coupons
http://pharmajetzt.com/# PharmaJetzt
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# prx online pharmacy
gГјnstigste versandapotheke: Pharma Jetzt – Pharma Jetzt
uriel pharmacy online store: Pharma Connect USA – malaysia pharmacy store
Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance amoxicilline et sport
https://pharmajetzt.com/# billig medikamente
Pharma Connect USA: buy priligy online pharmacy – Lisinopril
PharmaJetzt PharmaJetzt welche online apotheken gibt es
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
https://pharmajetzt.com/# PharmaJetzt
online apotheke deutschland: Pharma Jetzt – apotal – ihre versandapotheke
apteka nl: viata online apotheek – pharmacy online
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# Pharma Connect USA
mijn apotheek online mijn medicijnen bestellen MedicijnPunt
osco pharmacy: PharmaConnectUSA – Pharma Connect USA
https://medicijnpunt.shop/# mijn apotheek medicijnen
Pharma Connect USA: PharmaConnectUSA – target pharmacy bupropion
crГЁme franГ§aise Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance
http://medicijnpunt.com/# apothekers
bestell apotheke: apotheken im internet – PharmaJetzt
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# helicobacter pylori et foie
meijer pharmacy generic lipitor: viagra pharmacy malaysia – Pharma Connect USA
rx software pharmacy asda viagra in pharmacy Pharma Connect USA
https://pharmajetzt.com/# online apotheke versandkostenfrei auf rechnung
shop apitheke: PharmaJetzt – versand apotheke
Medicijn Punt: Medicijn Punt – medicijn bestellen
sams club pharmacy levitra online mexico pharmacy Pharma Connect USA
https://medicijnpunt.shop/# MedicijnPunt
netherlands pharmacy online: de online apotheek – pharmacy online netherlands
MedicijnPunt: Medicijn Punt – medicatielijst apotheek
https://medicijnpunt.shop/# online doktersrecept
Pharma Jetzt apotheke versand PharmaJetzt
http://pharmajetzt.com/# Pharma Jetzt
Pharma Confiance: viatris france – ouate pharmacie
pharmacie ouverte aujourd’hui lille: Pharma Confiance – ongles cannes pas cher
MedicijnPunt Medicijn Punt apotheken in holland
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# Pharma Connect USA
Pharma Jetzt: Pharma Jetzt – luipold apotheke
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
diovan online pharmacy online pharmacy lortab no prescription Pharma Connect USA
https://pharmaconfiance.com/# metronidazole pommade
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# PharmaJetzt
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
online versandapotheke Pharma Jetzt liefer apotheke
http://medicijnpunt.com/# MedicijnPunt
metaflow rabattcode: Pharma Jetzt – pillen apotheke
MedicijnPunt: apotgeek – MedicijnPunt
benadryl in france Pharma Confiance pharmacie libГ©ration nice
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# shopaptheke
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# Pharma Jetzt
Medicijn Punt: Medicijn Punt – digitale apotheek
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# singulair pharmacy coupon
Pharma Jetzt: apotheke auf rechnung bestellen – Pharma Jetzt
Pharma Confiance viagra pas chere Pharma Confiance
shop apothrke: Pharma Jetzt – Pharma Jetzt
http://medicijnpunt.com/# MedicijnPunt
MedicijnPunt: Medicijn Punt – online pharmacy nl
Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance Pharma Confiance
http://medicijnpunt.com/# Medicijn Punt
Pharma Confiance: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/# PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Jetzt: abotheke – apotheke bestellen schnell
peut on prendre amoxicilline et doliprane argel 7 en pharmacie avis Pharma Confiance
revive rx pharmacy: Pharma Connect USA – PharmaConnectUSA
http://pharmaconnectusa.com/# brookwood pharmacy artane
Medicijn Punt Medicijn Punt de apotheker
Pharma Connect USA: percocet in mexican pharmacy – Pharma Connect USA
https://medicijnpunt.shop/# apotheek spanje online
apotheke holland: MedicijnPunt – mijn medicijn bestellen
https://medicijnpunt.com/# internetapotheek spanje
MedicijnPunt Medicijn Punt MedicijnPunt
soolantra sans ordonnance: newpharma livraison – Pharma Confiance
Pharma Jetzt: PharmaJetzt – п»їonline apotheke
https://pharmajetzt.com/# PharmaJetzt
https://pharmajetzt.shop/# apotheken internet
online pharmacies legitimate PharmaConnectUSA Pharma Connect USA
Medicijn Punt: MedicijnPunt – Medicijn Punt
Pharma Confiance: pharmacie de garde eu – Pharma Confiance
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# Pharma Confiance
betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept: Medicijn Punt – Medicijn Punt
PharmaConnectUSA Pharma Connect USA which pharmacy has tamiflu
apotheje online: internet apotheke selbitz – shop apotheke meine bestellungen
https://papafarma.shop/# Papa Farma
https://svenskapharma.com/# apotek kontakt
spotes: kГ¶pa pГҐ nГ¤tet – Г¶versГ¤tt frГҐn engelska till svenska gratis
Papa Farma diprogenta pomada precio farmacia online barcelona barata
svovel sГҐpe apotek: Rask Apotek – Rask Apotek
https://efarmaciait.shop/# EFarmaciaIt
brentan crema precio sin receta: mejor mГ©dico digestivo palma de mallorca – Papa Farma
Svenska Pharma apotek hemleverans idag Svenska Pharma
https://efarmaciait.shop/# EFarmaciaIt
vape billigt: Svenska Pharma – bivax kГ¶pa apotek
Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – boraks apotek
EFarmaciaIt arcoxia 60 prezzo enterogermina equivalente
https://papafarma.com/# ozempic 0 50
best kundtjГ¤nst: mammaklГ¤der rea – Svenska Pharma
que es movicol: farmacua – farma segura
apotek webshop deodorant barn 8 ГҐr astmaspray receptfritt
http://raskapotek.com/# Rask Apotek
https://svenskapharma.shop/# Svenska Pharma
bomullshansker apotek: Rask Apotek – Rask Apotek
mg murcia: Papa Farma – Papa Farma
beställa medicin online Svenska Pharma Svenska Pharma
http://svenskapharma.com/# Svenska Pharma
elidel crema opinioni: EFarmaciaIt – EFarmaciaIt
EFarmaciaIt fucidin compresse EFarmaciaIt
https://raskapotek.com/# Rask Apotek
http://svenskapharma.com/# spotek
Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – apotek som er ГҐpent nГҐ
Svenska Pharma: bihГҐleinflammation engelska – Svenska Pharma
https://papafarma.com/# Papa Farma
Rask Apotek magnesiumkrem apotek Гёrerens apotek
Papa Farma: Papa Farma – Papa Farma
EFarmaciaIt flexiban per quanto tempo EFarmaciaIt
citrafleet amazon: casenlax jarabe niГ±os – cialis 5 mg precio en farmacia espaГ±a
https://svenskapharma.com/# Svenska Pharma
prisma 50 mg per quanto tempo: EFarmaciaIt – expose 100 a cosa serve
https://efarmaciait.shop/# augmentin prezzo con ricetta
Svenska Pharma bivax kГ¶pa apotek Svenska Pharma
EFarmaciaIt: EFarmaciaIt – EFarmaciaIt
http://papafarma.com/# farmacias cerca de mi ubicación
maltekstrakt apotek: apotrk – nakkekrage apotek
Papa Farma licoforte 40 mg gel farmacia farmacia aqui
https://efarmaciait.com/# amico farmacia
rГёd ris apotek: hallux valgus stГёtte apotek – Rask Apotek
https://papafarma.shop/# Papa Farma
EFarmaciaIt: EFarmaciaIt – bentelan quanto costa
EFarmaciaIt bassado costo EFarmaciaIt
EFarmaciaIt: EFarmaciaIt – gentamicina crema senza ricetta
https://papafarma.com/# epiduo forte precio farmacia
cГіmo llegar a parque alcosa: tadalafilo 20 mg precio en espaГ±a – farmacias online baratas
https://raskapotek.com/# Rask Apotek
kolla mina recept snabbtest hiv apotek Г¶ppna apotek
https://medsfrommexico.shop/# Meds From Mexico
buying prescription drugs in mexico online: Meds From Mexico – mexico drug stores pharmacies
mexican mail order pharmacies: medicine in mexico pharmacies – Meds From Mexico
the canadian pharmacy reputable canadian online pharmacies canada drugs online review
https://canadapharmglobal.com/# best online canadian pharmacy
maple leaf pharmacy in canada: rate canadian pharmacies – canadian pharmacy in canada
canadian drug prices: canadian pharmacy cheap – canadian mail order pharmacy
mexican drugstore online Meds From Mexico п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
https://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
http://canadapharmglobal.com/# canadian pharmacy tampa
reputable indian online pharmacy: India Pharm Global – best india pharmacy
canadianpharmacy com canadian pharmacies that deliver to the us canadian drug prices
Meds From Mexico: Meds From Mexico – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
https://canadapharmglobal.shop/# canadianpharmacyworld com
medication canadian pharmacy: Canada Pharm Global – canadian discount pharmacy
http://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
top 10 pharmacies in india top 10 pharmacies in india indian pharmacy paypal
http://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global
Meds From Mexico: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – Meds From Mexico
reputable indian pharmacies: India Pharm Global – India Pharm Global
https://canadapharmglobal.shop/# canadian pharmacy price checker
top 10 pharmacies in india India Pharm Global indian pharmacy
India Pharm Global: indian pharmacy online – reputable indian online pharmacy
Meds From Mexico: mexican rx online – Meds From Mexico
https://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
https://medsfrommexico.shop/# Meds From Mexico
canadian pharmacy 365 Canada Pharm Global canadian pharmacy world
best online pharmacies in mexico: mexican rx online – medicine in mexico pharmacies
buying prescription drugs in mexico online: medicine in mexico pharmacies – Meds From Mexico
https://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
Meds From Mexico: mexican mail order pharmacies – Meds From Mexico
buying prescription drugs in mexico mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs best online pharmacies in mexico
canadian pharmacy india: best canadian online pharmacy – www canadianonlinepharmacy
https://canadapharmglobal.shop/# adderall canadian pharmacy
https://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global
India Pharm Global: п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india – India Pharm Global
buying from online mexican pharmacy Meds From Mexico best online pharmacies in mexico
ed drugs online from canada: Canada Pharm Global – canadian neighbor pharmacy
http://indiapharmglobal.com/# India Pharm Global
Generic Crestor for high cholesterol: CrestorPharm – Order rosuvastatin online legally
LipiPharm LipiPharm LipiPharm
Semaglu Pharm: SemagluPharm – Semaglu Pharm
https://semaglupharm.shop/# what happens if you take rybelsus with food
http://crestorpharm.com/# why was rosuvastatin banned
Semaglu Pharm: Rybelsus for blood sugar control – SemagluPharm
prednisone 40 mg tablet PredniPharm PredniPharm
http://semaglupharm.com/# FDA-approved Rybelsus alternative
can crestor cause depression: CrestorPharm – Over-the-counter Crestor USA
PredniPharm: PredniPharm – where to buy prednisone 20mg
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Semaglu Pharm
Semaglu Pharm Semaglu Pharm Semaglu Pharm
Lipi Pharm: LipiPharm – Atorvastatin online pharmacy
https://lipipharm.com/# atorvastatin online
Predni Pharm: Predni Pharm – can you buy prednisone in canada
https://semaglupharm.com/# Order Rybelsus discreetly
Semaglu Pharm Affordable Rybelsus price Rybelsus online pharmacy reviews
USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery: does lipitor cause weight loss – Lipi Pharm
http://semaglupharm.com/# Rybelsus for blood sugar control
Predni Pharm: Predni Pharm – order prednisone online no prescription
Predni Pharm cost of prednisone in canada prednisone without prescription
where to buy prednisone without prescription: steroids prednisone for sale – prednisone online for sale
https://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm
http://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm
CrestorPharm: does crestor lower triglycerides – Crestor Pharm
Semaglu Pharm Rybelsus online pharmacy reviews rybelsus 14 mg coupon
prednisone 4mg: prednisone 2.5 tablet – Predni Pharm
https://semaglupharm.shop/# SemagluPharm
Crestor Pharm: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm
PredniPharm PredniPharm PredniPharm
LipiPharm: LipiPharm – LipiPharm
https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm
Affordable cholesterol-lowering pills: Generic Crestor for high cholesterol – is there generic for crestor
LipiPharm Lipi Pharm metformin and lipitor
http://crestorpharm.com/# Crestor Pharm
Semaglu Pharm: Affordable Rybelsus price – Semaglu Pharm
Lipi Pharm: Lipi Pharm – LipiPharm
SemagluPharm what does rybelsus look like Online pharmacy Rybelsus
Predni Pharm: Predni Pharm – prednisone for sale without a prescription
Semaglu Pharm: Semaglu Pharm – SemagluPharm
http://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm
Semaglu Pharm: SemagluPharm – SemagluPharm
prednisone 1 mg for sale: PredniPharm – 80 mg prednisone daily
Semaglu Pharm rybelsus precio farmacia guadalajara rybelsus not working
https://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglu Pharm
Crestor Pharm: Best price for Crestor online USA – Best price for Crestor online USA
SemagluPharm: rybelsus dose equivalent to ozempic – Semaglu Pharm
http://semaglupharm.com/# Affordable Rybelsus price
what is atorvastatin calcium Safe atorvastatin purchase without RX Order cholesterol medication online
https://lipipharm.shop/# LipiPharm
Predni Pharm: Predni Pharm – prednisone for sale without a prescription
Crestor Pharm: п»їBuy Crestor without prescription – CrestorPharm
Online pharmacy Rybelsus SemagluPharm rybelsus vs victoza
http://lipipharm.com/# Lipi Pharm
rosuvastatin paxlovid: CrestorPharm – rosuvastatin and insomnia
Semaglu Pharm: Semaglu Pharm – semaglutide and pregnancy
lipitor is used for LipiPharm Lipi Pharm
rosuvastatin cause diarrhea: Crestor Pharm – Safe online pharmacy for Crestor
Predni Pharm: prednisone without prescription 10mg – PredniPharm
Order rosuvastatin online legally Crestor Pharm does taking crestor cause weight gain
https://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm
alternatives to crestor: Best price for Crestor online USA – Crestor Pharm
Crestor Pharm: Crestor Pharm – Crestor Pharm
CrestorPharm Crestor Pharm Crestor Pharm
CrestorPharm: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm
Crestor Pharm: where is crestor manufactured – rosuvastatin atorvastatin
Crestor Pharm п»їBuy Crestor without prescription cost of rosuvastatin
https://prednipharm.shop/# prednisone prices
can i take my semaglutide a day early: does semaglutide help with inflammation – No prescription diabetes meds online
Predni Pharm: prednisone 20 mg purchase – PredniPharm
Semaglu Pharm Semaglu Pharm Affordable Rybelsus price
USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery: can lipitor – rosuvastatin and atorvastatin are same
is rybelsus for diabetes: is ozempic semaglutide – semaglutide name brand
PredniPharm Predni Pharm PredniPharm
LipiPharm: LipiPharm – Safe atorvastatin purchase without RX
CrestorPharm: does rosuvastatin cause weight loss – Order rosuvastatin online legally
http://prednipharm.com/# prednisone 10mg prices
CrestorPharm: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm
CrestorPharm CrestorPharm Online statin therapy without RX
$3 crestor: Crestor Pharm – Best price for Crestor online USA
lipitor cause weight loss: Discreet shipping for Lipitor – Discreet shipping for Lipitor
Crestor Pharm: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm
Predni Pharm: PredniPharm – PredniPharm
https://semaglupharm.shop/# Semaglu Pharm
PredniPharm: Predni Pharm – Predni Pharm
rybelsus 3mg for weight loss Affordable Rybelsus price SemagluPharm
Lipi Pharm: Lipi Pharm – Online statin drugs no doctor visit
LipiPharm: Order cholesterol medication online – what can i take instead of lipitor
PredniPharm prednisone 20mg tablets where to buy Predni Pharm
LipiPharm: LipiPharm – can you cut atorvastatin in half
Predni Pharm: Predni Pharm – PredniPharm
http://crestorpharm.com/# Crestor Pharm
LipiPharm: can atorvastatin cause ear problems – LipiPharm
CrestorPharm: what time of day to take rosuvastatin – does crestor help triglycerides
Order Rybelsus discreetly SemagluPharm rybelsus farmacia guadalajara
No RX Lipitor online: does atorvastatin help you lose weight – lipitor sex drive
PredniPharm: prednisone 20mg capsule – 6 prednisone
https://prednipharm.shop/# prednisone 60 mg price
price of prednisone tablets: PredniPharm – prednisone 1 mg for sale
Lipi Pharm: п»їBuy Lipitor without prescription USA – LipiPharm
PredniPharm PredniPharm PredniPharm
side effects for atorvastatin: LipiPharm – what foods should be avoided when taking atorvastatin?
cheap viagra for sale online: buy genuine viagra online – can i buy viagra in australia
where can i get viagra in canada: viagra pill cost canada – price for sildenafil 100 mg
generic sildenafil 20mg cost order sildenafil 20 mg sildenafil online purchase in india
where can i order generic viagra online: viagra 100mg australia – female viagra 100mg
https://vgrsources.com/# buy generic sildenafil uk
over the counter viagra in us: VGR Sources – over the counter viagra for women
best online price for viagra: where can i get viagra prescription – pfizer viagra 100mg
best price real viagra VGR Sources viagra 50mg tablets price in india
how to get viagra in india: price of 50 mg viagra – how do i buy viagra
viagra purchase buy: VGR Sources – sildenafil no prescription
buy viagra over the counter: VGR Sources – can you order viagra online
how much is viagra in australia viagra price uk viagra womens
can you purchase viagra over the counter in canada: VGR Sources – over the counter viagra in canada
order female viagra online: VGR Sources – buy generic viagra without prescription
where to buy viagra online usa: cipla viagra – over the counter viagra united states
https://vgrsources.com/# viagra alternative
sildenafil tablets 150mg sildenafil in singapore buy generic viagra online cheap
how to buy over the counter viagra: cost of 100mg viagra pill – women viagra pills
viagra 50 mg online: VGR Sources – where can i get viagra
generic viagra online in usa: where to get viagra over the counter – cheap generic sildenafil citrate
no prescription viagra canada where can i order real viagra viagra online pharmacy usa
viagra price in south africa: viagra by pfizer – sildenafil citrate vs viagra
viagra tablet canada: VGR Sources – buying generic viagra online
buy viagra usa: VGR Sources – viagra super active online
https://vgrsources.com/# buy viagra over the counter in canada
can i order viagra online VGR Sources buy generic viagra online canada
viagra in south africa: precio viagra 50mg – buy viagra soft tabs
where can i buy over the counter sildenafil: VGR Sources – viagra gel caps
20 mg viagra daily: find viagra – generic viagra online pharmacy canada
order brand name viagra online VGR Sources viagra canada otc
best women viagra: VGR Sources – viagra pill for women
online pharmacy viagra no prescription: Viagra 50 mg Fiyat – cheapest generic sildenafil uk
sildenafil 90mg: VGR Sources – generic viagra 25
https://vgrsources.com/# viagra generic 50 mg
how do i buy viagra 60 mg viagra femail viagra
female viagra capsule: viagra canada online price – where can i buy viagra online in india
viagra generic online pharmacy: sildenafil 50mg brand name – purchase viagra in india
viagra super active: VGR Sources – purchase viagra in usa
female viagra pill buy buy viagra online canada pharmacy how to get female viagra pill
viagra generic online cheapest: VGR Sources – sildenafil 20 mg online canada
sildenafil 100mg india: VGR Sources – cheap viagra online canada
viagra 100mg price in usa: VGR Sources – over the counter female viagra canada
how to buy generic viagra VGR Sources viagra pills price in south africa
https://vgrsources.com/# sildenafil 20 mg online pharmacy
100mg viagra price in india: viagra tabs – female viagra price
buy generic viagra with paypal: canada viagra otc – order viagra from uk
can you buy viagra in mexico VGR Sources can you buy sildenafil otc
viagra in india online: where can i buy viagra in usa – viagra for sale without prescription
cheapest generic viagra online: how can i get a prescription for viagra – cheap generic india viagra
discount viagra: VGR Sources – lowest cost for viagra
https://vgrsources.com/# viagra mastercard online pharmacy
viagra super active plus VGR Sources get viagra prescription online
buy real viagra canada: VGR Sources – buy sildenafil citrate 100mg
100mg sildenafil online: VGR Sources – viagra 200mg tablet
generic viagra online no prescription: where to buy viagra online safely – best prices for viagra in canada
order sildenafil uk viagra 25mg online buy generic viagra canada
viagra without prescriptions: online viagra prescription – sildenafil 50 coupon
how much is viagra uk: VGR Sources – best buy viagra online
https://vgrsources.com/# buy female viagra pills in india
viagra 150 mg pills: VGR Sources – generic viagra soft gel capsule
sildenafil 100mg price women viagra sildenafil online free shipping
female viagra online pharmacy: VGR Sources – female viagra capsules in india
rx pharmacy coupons Pharm Express 24 generic viagra online pharmacy no prescription
methotrexate prices pharmacy: Pharm Express 24 – community pharmacy audit methotrexate
buy medicin: best medicine to buy in mexico – the mexican pharmacy online
https://pharmexpress24.shop/# reputable online pharmacy viagra
mexican pharmacy pain killers Pharm Mex ozempic in mexico name
india medical: buy medicine from india – india pharmacy delivery
india pharmacy cialis prescription drugs from india retail pharmacy market in india
online pharmacy shop: safe mexican online pharmacy – overseas pharmacy
meloxicam online pharmacy Pharm Express 24 rx express pharmacy navarre fl
https://pharmexpress24.com/# online pharmacy stock order viagra
clozapine pharmacy registry: global rx pharmacy – people’s pharmacy wellbutrin
krogers pharmacy Finax adderall online pharmacy
mexican online stores: mexican pharmacy on line – mexico pharmacy
online pharmacy cialis no prescription: pharmacy app store – viagra usa online pharmacy
viagra cancun pharmacy: humana pharmacy online – skip’s pharmacy low dose naltrexone
order medicine online india india pharmacy international shipping drugs from india
pharmacy artane: provigil internet pharmacy – india online pharmacy store
https://pharmexpress24.com/# reputable online pharmacy no prescription
online medical store india apotheke academy first online pharmacy in india
prescription drugs from india: medical store online – ozempic india pharmacy
mexican ritalin: mail order pharmacy names – can you get ritalin over the counter in mexico
finding ozempic in stock Pharm Mex mexico pharmacy
viagra online pharmacy: Pharm Express 24 – med rx pharmacy
http://pharmmex.com/# mexican pharmacy in mexico
drugs from india: InPharm24 – when first pharmacy course was started in india
can you buy cialis over the counter in mexico best things to get at a mexican pharmacy mexican pharmacy price list
flomax online pharmacy: cialis from india online pharmacy – mexican pharmacy wellbutrin
klonopin mexican pharmacy Pharm Mex can you buy pain pills in mexico
amoxicillin from mexico: drugs on line – best mexican pharmacy
mexico farmacia: Pharm Mex – penicillin mexico
http://pharmexpress24.com/# online pharmacy cytotec no prescription
prescriptions from india medications from india buy online medicine
pharmacy chains in india: InPharm24 – pharmacy franchises in india
can you buy prednisone in mexico: mexican pharmacy anavar – buy mounjaro online mexico
legal online pharmacy coupon code: handling methotrexate in pharmacy – generic propecia online pharmacy
Etodolac buy isotretinoin online pharmacy pharmacy store hours
http://pharmmex.com/# rx mexico
Aebgjoync: buy pharmacy – ez rx pharmacy
medications from india: InPharm24 – apollo pharmacy india
buy medicine from india india rx india pharmacy reviews
indoxen 25 mg prezzo: Farmacia Subito – оземпик купить РІ италии
brosse Г dent gum Pharmacie Express ordonnance en ligne cystite
http://pharmacieexpress.com/# peut-on acheter du viagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance
spray nasale avamys prezzo: zitromax sospensione orale – zitromax sciroppo
migpriv sans ordonnance: ordonnance gratuite – arcalion sans ordonnance
prix bas de contention sans ordonnance mГ©dicament pour dormir sans ordonnance en pharmacie zelesse gel intime
fluimucil aerosol prezzo: cerotti antinfiammatori – aircort per aerosol
farmacia italia online: Farmacia Subito – senshio compresse prezzo
gelГ©e ultra fresh jouvence peut on acheter kГ©toprofГЁne sans ordonnance creme epitheliale
augmentin farmacia online: farmacia online candidiasis – weleda farmacia online
https://pharmacieexpress.com/# peut on acheter du viagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance au quebec
diurГ©tique naturel puissant pharmacie sans ordonnance: equivalent viagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance – anxiolitique sans ordonnance
estudiar farmacia online se puede comprar aldactone sin receta farmacia barata online
cialis 20mg sans ordonnance: sildenafil mylan 100 mg achat en ligne – clarelux 500 sans ordonnance
acheter tadalafil en ligne sans ordonnance: Pharmacie Express – viagra sans ordonnance 24h pharmacie
comprar hormonas femeninas sin receta farmacia manacor online farmacia carol compra online
ordonnance securisée: calcipotriol sans ordonnance – peut on aller a la pharmacie de garde sans ordonnance
https://confiapharma.com/# comprar alprostadil sin receta
quГ© pastillas para dormir puedo comprar sin receta farmacia 365 online farmacia online mascarillas con filtro
asamax 800: frequil 100 – bentelan al cane
slowmet 750: farmacia online sconto – punture pappataci come riconoscerle
klacid 250: Farmacia Subito – zitromax sospensione orale
binocrit prezzo: prometrium 200 – aminomal fiale prezzo
pilule sans ordonnance pharmacie: Pharmacie Express – commande viagra
pharmacie vente sans ordonnance: drogue pharmacie sans ordonnance – attelle cheville pharmacie sans ordonnance
augmentin prezzo con ricetta: sibilla pillola – trittico contramid 150
serpens 320 mg prezzo: fluimucil 300 mg per aerosol prezzo – ranexa 500 prezzo
cursos online farmacia y parafarmacia: mifepristona se puede comprar sin receta – comprar permetrina sin receta
kamagra oral jelly: acheter kamagra site fiable – kamagra oral jelly