

Author(s): Kingsley Ighobor
Date of Publication: December 2016-March 2017
Osahon Enabulele, a former president of the Nigerian Medical Association, estimates there are about 8,000 Nigerian doctors in the United States. Yet in their motherland, only about 35,000 doctors attend to the country’s 173 million citizens, according to Folashade Ogunsola, a professor of medicine and chairman of the Association of Colleges of Medicine of Nigeria.
The World Health Organization (WHO), the UN body responsible for promoting international public health, puts Nigeria’s doctor-to-population ratio at 0.3 per 1,000 persons, which is grossly inadequate. The country needs at least 237,000 doctors, says Dr. Enabulele.
According to 2015 WHO data, the doctor-to-population ratio in Liberia and Sierra Leone (two countries recently hit by the Ebola epidemic) is even worse: 51 doctors for Liberia’s population of 4.5 million (0.1 per 1,000 people) and 136 doctors for Sierra Leone’s 6 million people (0.2 per 1,000). Ethiopia has 0.2 doctors per 1,000 and Uganda has 0.12 doctors per 1,000 inhabitants, while South Africa and Egypt, at 4.3 and 2.8 per 1,000 respectively, have better ratios.
In search of greener pastures
“About 44% of WHO member states have less than one doctor per 1,000 population,” reported the health body in 2015. “Countries with the lowest relative need have the highest numbers of health workers, while those with the greatest burden of disease must make do with a much smaller health workforce.”
Africa bears “more than 24% of the global burden of disease, but has access to only 3% of health workers and less than 1% of the world’s financial resources,” according to WHO.
Financial losses mount
Countries that invest in the training of health workers suffer financial losses when these educated professionals emigrate, according to a 2011 research by a group of Canadian scientists led by Edward Mills, chair of global health at the University of Ottawa. The researchers studied nine sub-Saharan African countries (Ethiopia, Kenya, Malawi, Nigeria, South Africa, Tanzania, Uganda, Zambia and Zimbabwe) and estimated that these countries suffered a loss of about $2.1 billion from investments for all doctors working in destination countries up to 2010. It costs African nations between $21,000 and $59,000 to train each doctor, the Canadian team found.
Africa’s loss is rich countries’ gain: the research estimated that financial benefits amounted to $2.7 billion to the UK, $846 million to the United States, $621 million to Australia and $384 million to Canada. Rich countries should provide financial and logistical support to Africa’s health institutions, the researchers recommended.
Is brain drain a crime?
Some African and Western aid workers have referred to Africa’s medical brain drain as a crime, stirring a debate on the morality and legality of international medical recruitment.
In a 2011 article published by The Lancet, a British medical journal, the aid workers wrote, “High-income countries, such as Australia, Canada, Saudi Arabia, the US, the United Arab Emirates, and the UK have sustained their relatively high physician-to-population ratio by recruiting medical graduates from developing regions, including countries in sub-Saharan Africa.
In contrast, more than a half of the countries in sub-Saharan Africa do not meet the minimum acceptable physician-to-population ratio of 1-per-5,000 WHO standard.”
WHO’s code of practice on international recruitment of health care workers, adopted in 2010, in an attempt to tackle problems caused by medical brain drain, urged wealthy nations to support affected countries; however, the code is a moral guide rather than an enforceable legal instrument.
Stemming the flow of talent
Indications are that demand for health workers in Australia, Canada, the UK, the United States and other rich countries will continue to rise. The US Council on Physician and Nurse Supply estimates a shortage of 200,000 doctors between 2012 and 2022.
Laurie Garrett, a senior fellow at the US Council on Foreign Relations, concurs: “For the foreseeable future, every health provider [in the United States], from Harvard University’s health facilities all the way down to a rural clinic in the Ethiopian desert, is competing for medical talent, and the winners are those with money.”
A health worker from a poor country is good “for a diabetic or someone with heart disease in rural Nebraska,” writes Matt McAllester, a New York Times editor. “[Patients] may be unaware, however, that their gain is a poor country’s loss.”
Les Wathinotes sont soit des résumés de publications sélectionnées par WATHI, conformes aux résumés originaux, soit des versions modifiées des résumés originaux, soit des extraits choisis par WATHI compte tenu de leur pertinence par rapport au thème du Débat. Lorsque les publications et leurs résumés ne sont disponibles qu’en français ou en anglais, WATHI se charge de la traduction des extraits choisis dans l’autre langue. Toutes les Wathinotes renvoient aux publications originales et intégrales qui ne sont pas hébergées par le site de WATHI, et sont destinées à promouvoir la lecture de ces documents, fruit du travail de recherche d’universitaires et d’experts.
The Wathinotes are either original abstracts of publications selected by WATHI, modified original summaries or publication quotes selected for their relevance for the theme of the Debate. When publications and abstracts are only available either in French or in English, the translation is done by WATHI. All the Wathinotes link to the original and integral publications that are not hosted on the WATHI website. WATHI participates to the promotion of these documents that have been written by university professors and experts.
265 Commentaires. En écrire un nouveau
onlin apotheke: Pharma Jetzt – online apotheken vergleich
test pdg pharmacie tena culotte Pharma Confiance
ordre des pharmaciens contact: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
https://medicijnpunt.com/# Medicijn Punt
PharmaJetzt: Pharma Jetzt – fledox in apotheke kaufen
https://pharmajetzt.com/# PharmaJetzt
percocet online pharmacy no prescription: retail pharmacy price cialis – Pharma Connect USA
parapharmacie cormelles le royal: god souple – fiГЁvre 24h aprГЁs une chute bГ©bГ©
http://medicijnpunt.com/# betrouwbare online apotheek
Medicijn Punt: snel medicijnen bestellen – MedicijnPunt
medikament kaufen: PharmaJetzt – PharmaJetzt
https://pharmaconfiance.shop/# Pharma Confiance
PharmaJetzt: Pharma Jetzt – п»їonline apotheke
bestell apotheke apotheke m billigste online apotheke
parapharmaci: pharmacie de garde manche – pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es france
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# PharmaConnectUSA
Pharma Jetzt: Pharma Jetzt – PharmaJetzt
online pharmacy ambien no prescription: PharmaConnectUSA – allopurinol online pharmacy
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# cytotec pharmacy
Pharma Jetzt: medizin online bestellen – PharmaJetzt
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
aporheke: shop apotheke auf rechnung – online apotheke deutschland
comment prendre cariban ozempic france prix amoxicilline et hГ©morroГЇdes
Pharma Jetzt: apotheke online – online apotheke auf rechnung
https://pharmaconnectusa.com/# pom pharmacy viagra
Pharma Confiance: parapharmacie en ligne france – Pharma Confiance
rite aid pharmacy store hours: viagra pharmacy australia – avodart pharmacy
https://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
online apotheke ohne anmeldung: PharmaJetzt – Pharma Jetzt
PharmaConnectUSA: online pharmacy uk no prescription viagra – PharmaConnectUSA
http://pharmaconfiance.com/# Pharma Confiance
Pharma Connect USA: house pharmacy finpecia – differin gel pharmacy
daflon 1000 prix pharmacie: Pharma Confiance – Pharma Confiance
https://pharmaconnectusa.shop/# PharmaConnectUSA
https://efarmaciait.shop/# efarma tempi spedizione
http://raskapotek.com/# Rask Apotek
apotek hГҐndkrem: retinol apotek – Rask Apotek
https://efarmaciait.shop/# dieta rad
farmacia en madrid: Papa Farma – brentan crema in english
Papa Farma: Papa Farma – tramadol comprar
https://svenskapharma.com/# apotek graviditetstest
EFarmaciaIt: per quanto tempo prendere normix – isodifa 30 mg
Svenska Pharma: billiga l-stГ¶d – collagen apotek
http://svenskapharma.com/# Svenska Pharma
Rask Apotek: Rask Apotek – blodtype test apotek
https://svenskapharma.shop/# kГ¶pa frakt
EFarmaciaIt: flubason crema cosa serve – vermox bambini sciroppo
https://raskapotek.com/# Rask Apotek
bactroban nasale opinioni: EFarmaciaIt – EFarmaciaIt
http://canadapharmglobal.com/# canadian pharmacy world
india online pharmacy: India Pharm Global – best india pharmacy
Meds From Mexico: reputable mexican pharmacies online – mexican pharmaceuticals online
http://indiapharmglobal.com/# п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
canadian pharmacy 24h com: legit canadian pharmacy online – best canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacy 24h: ordering drugs from canada – best canadian online pharmacy
https://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
https://canadapharmglobal.com/# canadian pharmacy 365
India Pharm Global: India Pharm Global – India Pharm Global
https://medsfrommexico.com/# Meds From Mexico
India Pharm Global: indian pharmacies safe – India Pharm Global
http://medsfrommexico.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online
canada ed drugs: pharmacy com canada – reputable canadian pharmacy
http://indiapharmglobal.com/# online shopping pharmacy india
Meds From Mexico: mexican pharmaceuticals online – Meds From Mexico
prednisone 10mg online PredniPharm 50mg prednisone tablet
http://lipipharm.com/# atorvastatin recall 2025
apo prednisone: PredniPharm – PredniPharm
SemagluPharm: Semaglutide tablets without prescription – SemagluPharm
Order rosuvastatin online legally: can crestor cause high blood pressure – CrestorPharm
https://crestorpharm.shop/# Generic Crestor for high cholesterol
prednisone 5 mg: PredniPharm – buy prednisone online without a script
SemagluPharm: Order Rybelsus discreetly – Semaglu Pharm
https://lipipharm.com/# Atorvastatin online pharmacy
Generic Lipitor fast delivery: Lipi Pharm – atorvastatin 20 mg pill identifier
SemagluPharm: semaglutide weight loss price – Semaglu Pharm
https://prednipharm.com/# purchase prednisone
rybelsus side effects reviews: Rybelsus side effects and dosage – Affordable Rybelsus price
Semaglu Pharm: compounded semaglutide left out of fridge – Semaglu Pharm
PredniPharm prednisone 20mg nz PredniPharm
https://crestorpharm.com/# rosuvastatin calcium 20 mg tablet
Crestor home delivery USA: rosuvastatin 10 mg images – CrestorPharm
SemagluPharm: SemagluPharm – Semaglu Pharm
LipiPharm: what company makes lipitor – atorvastatin trade name
PredniPharm PredniPharm prednisone 15 mg daily
Semaglu Pharm: where can i get semaglutide near me – rybelsus vs jardiance weight loss
https://crestorpharm.shop/# CrestorPharm
PredniPharm: prednisone 10 mg over the counter – Predni Pharm
Lipi Pharm: how much does 20 mg atorvastatin lower cholesterol – LipiPharm
PredniPharm: PredniPharm – no prescription online prednisone
rybelsus mexico SemagluPharm Semaglu Pharm
Predni Pharm: can you buy prednisone online uk – Predni Pharm
Crestor Pharm: Crestor Pharm – Affordable cholesterol-lowering pills
http://crestorpharm.com/# what time of day is best to take crestor
Rybelsus 3mg 7mg 14mg SemagluPharm Semaglu Pharm
Affordable Rybelsus price: SemagluPharm – Semaglu Pharm
FDA-approved generic statins online: LipiPharm – Lipi Pharm
CrestorPharm: Rosuvastatin tablets without doctor approval – Crestor Pharm
Predni Pharm Predni Pharm Predni Pharm
LipiPharm: LipiPharm – livalo vs lipitor
prednisone 5mg capsules: Predni Pharm – prednisone cream
Safe atorvastatin purchase without RX: Lipi Pharm – Lipi Pharm
https://semaglupharm.com/# SemagluPharm
Lipi Pharm LipiPharm USA-based pharmacy Lipitor delivery
Affordable cholesterol-lowering pills: Best price for Crestor online USA – Crestor Pharm
semaglutide side effects reviews: SemagluPharm – Semaglu Pharm
Crestor Pharm Crestor Pharm Crestor Pharm
CrestorPharm: CrestorPharm – Crestor Pharm
where can you buy prednisone: canadian online pharmacy prednisone – india buy prednisone online
LipiPharm: Lipi Pharm – LipiPharm
Semaglu Pharm SemagluPharm Online pharmacy Rybelsus
http://crestorpharm.com/# CrestorPharm
Crestor 10mg / 20mg / 40mg online: Crestor Pharm – No doctor visit required statins
п»їBuy Crestor without prescription: Buy cholesterol medicine online cheap – Crestor Pharm
PredniPharm buy prednisone without prescription paypal PredniPharm
prednisone without prescription.net: prednisone over the counter south africa – PredniPharm
what happens if you miss a dose of rybelsus: Where to buy Semaglutide legally – SemagluPharm
LipiPharm: Lipi Pharm – lipitor indication
http://semaglupharm.com/# Semaglutide tablets without prescription
LipiPharm LipiPharm п»їBuy Lipitor without prescription USA
does lipitor cause headaches: LipiPharm – Safe atorvastatin purchase without RX
Crestor Pharm: Crestor home delivery USA – Over-the-counter Crestor USA
Semaglu Pharm: SemagluPharm – Online pharmacy Rybelsus
Predni Pharm can you buy prednisone over the counter in mexico prednisone 10 mg online
п»їBuy Rybelsus online USA: rybelsus 7mg side effects – Rybelsus side effects and dosage
http://prednipharm.com/# PredniPharm
prednisone 10mg tablet price: Predni Pharm – PredniPharm
Predni Pharm prednisone buy no prescription 80 mg prednisone daily
metformin and semaglutide: SemagluPharm – SemagluPharm
Crestor Pharm: should i take crestor – Safe online pharmacy for Crestor
ezetimibe with atorvastatin: Lipi Pharm – Atorvastatin online pharmacy
viagra pharmacy generic: VGR Sources – female viagra 100mg
lowest price for generic viagra: where is the best place to buy viagra online – price of viagra 100mg uk
cheap generic viagra no prescription VGR Sources where to buy cheap generic viagra
https://vgrsources.com/# buy viagra gel
150 mg sildenafil: VGR Sources – sildenafil 20 mg online prescription
viagra tablets australia cheap generic viagra cheap viagra 25
cheap viagra in australia: VGR Sources – compare sildenafil prices
where to get viagra in canada: VGR Sources – order viagra cheap online
generic viagra south africa: VGR Sources – india pharmacy viagra
sildenafil online mexico: female viagra 100mg tablet price in india – viagra comparison
viagra 100mg prices VGR Sources viagra united states
https://vgrsources.com/# viagra pills over the counter
buy viagra online usa: VGR Sources – sildenafil 50 coupon
viagra sildenafil: VGR Sources – sildenafil citrate generic viagra
sildenafil australia: where can you get female viagra – generic sildenafil prescription
buy viagra usa: VGR Sources – sildenafil citrate canada
otc viagra: viagra medication online – generic viagra online united states
buy sildenafil paypal: lowest price viagra 100mg – buy viagra new zealand
viagra buying canada VGR Sources cheap prescription viagra
https://vgrsources.com/# where to buy viagra in mexico
sildenafil 100mg for sale uk: VGR Sources – buy cheap generic viagra uk
viagra sublingual: VGR Sources – female viagra cost in india
sildenafil online: brand viagra australia – buy viagra online with paypal
online viagra from canada buy viagra medicine online india viagra generic canada
sildenafil tablets where to buy: buy viagra soft tabs – sildenafil 6mg
safe place to buy viagra: VGR Sources – sildenafil 100mg price india
viagra online using paypal: VGR Sources – cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy
purchase viagra VGR Sources real viagra online uk
viagra india 100mg: VGR Sources – cheap generic viagra online canada
https://vgrsources.com/# cheap generic viagra online usa
buy viagra online australia paypal: viagra 100 mg price in india – generic drug for viagra
viagra medicine online in india VGR Sources viagra professional pfizer
viagra 50mg price in india: VGR Sources – buy cheap viagra online us
female viagra tablet: VGR Sources – how to buy viagra online usa
viagra online canada no prescription: viagra 100mg tablet online in india – viagra for sale uk
buy generic viagra 50mg online VGR Sources buy viagra brand online
cheap viagra from canada: how can i get viagra over the counter – where to get viagra tablets
https://vgrsources.com/# 150 mg sildenafil
sildenafil canada cost: VGR Sources – buying sildenafil in mexico
viagra generic germany: buying viagra in europe – canada rx viagra
viagra 50 mg pill: VGR Sources – generic viagra otc
viagra buying canada VGR Sources viagra fast shipping
generic viagra from india: buy viagra generic online – where to buy sildenafil uk
where to buy generic viagra online: buy genuine viagra online canada – viagra 200mg uk
viagra 100mg price comparison buy sale viagra best online viagra site
https://vgrsources.com/# pfizer viagra
india viagra online: can i buy viagra over the counter in mexico – buy brand viagra
how can i get viagra over the counter: order prescription viagra online – purchase viagra india
viagra 100mg online buy: VGR Sources – viagra super active plus
viagra online cheap no prescription female viagra in australia sildenafil 10mg tablets
can you order viagra without a prescription: VGR Sources – cheap viagra online india
viagra 2018: VGR Sources – generic viagra singapore
sildenafil generic without prescription: VGR Sources – buy online viagra pills
sildenafil online for sale 3 viagra buy viagra from canada
https://vgrsources.com/# viagra pharmacy generic
discount pharmacy viagra: VGR Sources – mail order viagra canada
can i buy generic viagra in canada: viagra tablets canada – viagra pharmacy prices
compare generic viagra prices: VGR Sources – female viagra online canada
sildenafil prescription medicine lowest cost viagra online citrate sildenafil
cheap generic viagra in canada: buy viagra online canada with mastercard – how to get viagra cheap
cheap viagra buy: femail viagra – how to buy viagra tablets in india
mexican pharmacy chicago buy ozempic online mexico mounjaro in mexican pharmacy
baclofen pharmacy: mexican pharmacy celebrex – people’s pharmacy nexium
http://pharmexpress24.com/# generic lipitor online pharmacy
hispanic pharmacy near me: mexican mail order pharmacy – mexican pharmacy reviews
pharmacy chains in india online medical store india pharmacy india
prompt medical spine care: Pharm Mex – mexican chemist
lumbar spine pain management houston tijuana mexico pharmacy ritalin from mexico
pharmacy store in india: InPharm24 – online pharmacy in india
mexican pharmacy shipping: antibiotics mexican pharmacy – mexico medications
https://pharmmex.com/# online mexican pharmacies
fenofibrate online pharmacy price empower rx pharmacy ultram online pharmacy
tesco pharmacy zovirax: unicare pharmacy vardenafil – pharmacy rx by crystal zamudio
ex officio member of pharmacy council of india: india pharmacy delivery to usa – medicine from india
pharmacies in tijuana is mexican export pharmacy legit mexico pharmacy tijuana
best online pharmacy cialis: pharmacy at home viagra – zyprexa online pharmacy
boots pharmacy viagra cost: Pharm Express 24 – diovan pharmacy
mexican pharmacys: Pharm Mex – mexican pharmacy cozumel
can you buy oxycontin in mexico Pharm Mex good online mexican pharmacy
http://inpharm24.com/# medical store online
doxycycline the generics pharmacy: cialis cost pharmacy – care pharmacy rochester nh store hours
drugs from india: InPharm24 – india online pharmacy market
buy ambien us pharmacy meijer pharmacy free generic lipitor rx express pharmacy hurley ms
viagra prices pharmacy: ad rx pharmacy – online pharmacy europe
order from mexican pharmacy: can you buy zofran in mexico – online pharmacy ordering
mexican pharmacy ketamine: Pharm Mex – hispanic pharmacy near me
what prescriptions can you buy in mexico mounjaro price in mexico tramadol from mexico to us
https://pharmexpress24.com/# buy pharmacy
best indian pharmacy: buy drugs from india – list of pharmacies in india
mexican pharmacy near me: mexico tramadol – buy pharmaceuticals online
baclofen inhouse pharmacy pharmacy rx one review costa rica pharmacy percocet
mexican pharmacy viagra: best online pharmacy wellbutrin – unc student store pharmacy
indian pharmacies pharmacy from india buy medicines online
bupropion hcl xl global pharmacy: doxycycline pharmacy price – kroger pharmacy tamiflu
http://inpharm24.com/# top online pharmacy india
india online pharmacy: buy medicine online india – medicine online order
ozempic mail order pharmacy amoxicillin mexican mexico viagra pills
why is pharmacy rx: legit online pharmacy viagra – ambien pharmacy
doctor of pharmacy in india: InPharm24 – indian online pharmacy
https://pharmexpress24.shop/# sams club pharmacy lipitor
mexican pharmacy rohypnol wedgewood pharmacy naltrexone mexican pharmacy lortab
aciphex online pharmacy: target pharmacy hours – euro pharmacy cialis
united states online pharmacy: prilosec online pharmacy – price of percocet at pharmacy
https://pharmmex.shop/# online pharmacy us
online pharmacy india pharmacy online india get medicines from india
unicare pharmacy artane castle opening hours: Baycip – percocet pharmacy cost
movicol adulti acquisto on line Farmacia Subito vigorsol cult alaskan
tationil 600 prezzo: cholecomb 20/10 – elatrex principio attivo
pharmacie en ligne fiable sans ordonnance: hydrocortisone sans ordonnance – peut on acheter une minerve en pharmacie sans ordonnance
farmacia online souvenaid: se puede comprar viagra generico en farmacias sin receta – el paracetamol se puede comprar sin receta
farmacia online torrevieja Confia Pharma comprar farmacos sin receta
farmacia online san marino: Farmacia Subito – dona bustine prezzo
ketoderm creme sans ordonnance en pharmacie: Pharmacie Express – cialis 20mg generique
cynomel t3 en pharmacie sans ordonnance mal de dent medicament sans ordonnance cГ©lestГЁne sans ordonnance
netildex collirio prezzo monodose: Farmacia Subito – kyleena spirale
comprar medicamentos sin receta espaГ±a: comprar tobradex sin receta – saxenda se puede comprar sin receta mГ©dica
fungizone prix sans ordonnance ivermectine crГЁme sans ordonnance test covid en pharmacie sans ordonnance
ovaleap 900 prezzo: aminomal principio attivo – mictonorm 30 mg prezzo
finasteride 5 mg prezzo: muscoril 4 mg prezzo – mesalazina 800 prezzo
supracef 400 prezzo telfast 120 mascherine ffp3 farmacia online
indoxen 25 mg prezzo: my farmacia online – flixoderm crema acquisto online
http://farmaciasubito.com/# tadalafil 20 mg 4 compresse prezzo
serc se puede comprar sin receta: Confia Pharma – mifepristona comprar sin receta
sildenafil en pharmacie sans ordonnance crГЁme epitheliale viagra homme 50 mg
farmacia económica online: Confia Pharma – farmacia selma online
dubine crema prezzo: Farmacia Subito – lasonil compresse 600 mg
comprar mascarillas quirurgicas farmacia online: farmacia online lasix – farmacia online venta mascarillas
dostinex 8 compresse prezzo toradol sublinguale annister 10000
argotone neonato 1 mese: Farmacia Subito – cholecomb 5/10 prezzo
monuril prezzo: farmacia on line sicura – farmacia online castel del monte
università farmacia online: eminocs prezzo – algix 90 prezzo
farmacia online san vicente del raspeig: farmacia online farmex – farmacia online sergas
busette cerotto 20 mg: fentanil cerotto 25 – niferex 100
médicament pour bander sans ordonnance en pharmacie: seringue sans aiguille pharmacie sans ordonnance – symbicort sans ordonnance
kamagra en ligne: kamagra en ligne – livraison discrète Kamagra